American Idol judge Randy Jackson is taking a good deal of ribbing for his comment that American Idol is “the Olympics for Singers”.
I get it Randy. You are defending the theme weeks. However, Olympics is a bit over the top. But while it is over the top, it wasn’t the most important part of what you said. I’m gonna get your back dawg.
I give you a huge pass because of some of the other things you says in the interview. Peep this:
"Here's the problem with [contemporary theme weeks] — guess what? It's a competition. I know that you know the latest Lady Gaga song," Jackson told MTV News. "I happen to think that songs of yesteryear are better songs and are harder to sing, so they create more difficulty for you who listens to the radio everyday."
Jackson explained that "Idol" competitors have to prove that they have the pipes to take on the big songs — so if you want to sing a Ke$ha tune, "Idol" may not be the show for you. (Although Jackson hopes that Ke$ha takes no offense to that.) "Give me Sinatra. Give me somebody who's just really emoting and engaging and making you believe.
"Give me Motown," he continued about the advantages of singing older songs instead of newer hits by newer artists. "Give me the greatest rock band ever, in my estimation — Led Zeppelin. The degree of difficulty to play Led Zeppelin music, let alone sing it, is so off the Richter scale. This is a competition. 'Idol' is like the Olympics for singers. We want to make it tougher for them."
I agree with Randy 100 Million percent. If American Idol was a bunch of kids singing today’s pop music, I wouldn’t watch. And guess what, lots of other people would quit watching too. The music is uninteresting as is. No one wants to hear an amateur do the karaoke version of it. Are there theme weeks I don’t care for? Sure. But if the finalists could pick whatever they wanted every week it would be a dumpster fire.
I’m so glad Randy chose Ke$ha as his example. I find her music grating at best. Auto-tuners and bad songwriting just don’t do it for me. I think they don’t do it for Randy either. He says he hopes she takes no offense, but his point it made.
[And yes, you did just see me type the phrase “peep this” above.]
Recent Comments